Monday, January 14, 2013

Making Meaning (as Opposed to the “Ultimate” Rhetorical Device)

A Catholic friend asked:
Pat (and whomever else), I wonder if you would indulge me and give me a response to this blog post. I am trying to come to terms and understand more with the mind of an atheist. Can you help me?
He provided to this link. It's an excerpt from a book of Christian apologetics.

Here's my response:

Making Meaning (as Opposed to the “Ultimate” Rhetorical Device)

I don’t want my life’s meaning determined by an invisible, unaccountable, mythical, supernatural authority figure who allegedly “works in mysterious ways.”* Handing off my sense of meaning to such a vague character would deprive me of creating meaning for my own life.

To Christian ears this often sounds like arrogance, but it isn’t. It sounds as though I’m putting myself above the Almighty, but that’s impossible. I can’t put myself above something that I don’t believe exists. If someone asked you your appraisal of the mightiness of Zeus, would your denial of Zeus’ existence be arrogance? No. Your disbelief in Zeus is probably identical to my disbelief in God.

I do understand the emotional appeal of believing one is part of a grand story that will go on forever. There was a time I shared that belief.
When I realized my cherished beliefs were flawed, the loss of my prospective afterlife was the most difficult part to accept. I was really looking forward to an afterlife, provided it didn’t get too boring.

However, within a couple weeks of my loss of faith, while walking on Michigan Ave. near Greenfield, I was struck by a powerful realization. As I neared the K-Mart parking lot I had an epiphany:

This life and my present awareness became vastly more precious. When I was a believer, I had been in the Augustine and Kierkegaard funk of life—this “test for the afterlife,” this “vale of tears,” this “mortal coil.” Suddenly I shed all that dreariness and began to appreciate the fact that I’m here at all. Life became more valuable and my ability to create meaning became a part of what freedom means to me today, decades later.

I also became a much happier person—this too was a surprise.

There is a kind of “optical illusion” quality to differences of belief. When I believed in God, my faith was linked to very basic concepts—particularly my sense of value. I was surprised to discover that changing my answer on the God question resulted in almost no changes in my sense of value.

So where do I find meaning? Are there people I love? Yes. Are there creatures that are capable of pleasure and suffering? Yes. There’s plenty of meaning in all that already.

Let’s get to the blog post.

The link title suggests that the post is about hope. Actually, the post is about meaning. The two concepts do overlap but they are different. I’ll stick to the (familiar) argument in the post regarding whether atheists can have meaning in their lives. (Inhale, exhale.)

Just so you know, Christians can sound extremely condescending when this argument is presented. We give this a pass because of the “optical illusion” problem mentioned above. You’re probably not trying to condescend. It’s forgiven. But please consider this: Christians do not have a monopoly on living a meaningful life.

OK, let’s get into this. The book excerpt by Dr. William Lane Craig has a lot of problems but I’ll stick with the most important ones.

Dr. Craig’s argument uses the “ultimate” rhetorical device:
If each individual person passes out of existence when he dies, then what ultimate meaning can be given to his life?

Does it really matter whether he ever existed at all?

It might be said that his life was important because it influenced others or affected the course of history. But this only shows a relative significance to his life, not an ultimate significance.
I thought gluttony was supposed to be a sin—how much significance does a guy need? The word “ultimate” appears 14 times in the blog post and his argument depends upon the word. Well, any amount is insignificant when compared to the eternal and infinite. The comparison is a rhetorical device. It dismisses the temporary and the finite—what Craig calls “relative”—as meaningless.

By analogy, the number one-million is greater than eleven. “Ah, but they are both equally insignificant when compared to infinity!” No mathematician would find this infinity gambit interesting. One-million is still more than eleven, relative claim though it is.

The Craig excerpt concludes with some very brief summaries of literature, cherry-picked from existentialists. I’d gone through my own existentialism phase and Craig gets some of this stuff wrong, but that’s beside the point. Existentialists do not speak for most atheists (at least not ones outside of France).

In my experience, most atheists in the English-speaking world are rationalists. Very few are nihilists (which is what Craig’s argument suggests). There are plenty of atheists who are more eloquent on this subject than I—if you want, I can provide plenty of links. For now, I’ll refer you to Julia Sweeney’s excellent story on This American Life:

The full audio is available at the link. Her story is very similar to mine, including her similar epiphany on life. It’s heartfelt, funny, and more representative of the naturalism shared by most of the atheists I know.

*This is leaving aside the horrible personage depicted in a famous collection of ancient Jewish folk literature.


Anonymous said...

free bbw sex dating sims dating games online

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I really appreciate your efforts and I am
waiting for your further write ups thanks once again.
Also see my page: Maestro Debit Card

Anonymous said...

the yanti ebook how to make ebook covers [url=]software project management free ebook download[/url] make free ebook covers mac

Anonymous said...

ebook devices including palm free c how to progam ebook [url=]olympische fruhling free ebook[/url] ebook and sex and games

Anonymous said...

Hey there! This is my first visit to your blog!
We are a collection of volunteers and starting a new project in a community in the same niche.
Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.

You have done a extraordinary job!

Feel free to visit my web-site - buy a car
Also visit my weblog : buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

I could not resist commenting. Very well written!

Feel free to visit my web page; how to buy a car with bad credit
Here is my web page - buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

david carnoy ebook torrent antssoft ebook maker crack [url=]free card trick ebook downloads[/url] ebook reader 1150

Anonymous said...

What i do not realize is actually how you're no longer really a lot more well-favored than you might be now. You are very intelligent. You realize thus significantly in terms of this subject, produced me in my opinion believe it from so many numerous angles. Its like men and women don't
seem to be fascinated unless it's one thing to do with Woman gaga! Your individual stuffs outstanding. At all times maintain it up!

Here is my web page :: sell structured settlements for minors

Anonymous said...

Howdy would you mind letting me know which webhost you're utilizing? I've loaded your blog in 3 completely different
web browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot quicker then most.
Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at
a fair price? Kudos, I appreciate it!

Also visit my page; annuity payments for powerball

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing your thoughts about settlement cash.

My web blog purchase structured settlement

Anonymous said...

Hi there just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your content seem to be running off the screen
in Internet explorer. I'm not sure if this is a format issue or something to do with browser compatibility but I figured I'd post to let you know.

The layout look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon.

Look at my homepage: structured settlement cash

Anonymous said...

Hi there, after reading this amazing piece of writing i am as well delighted to share my knowledge here with colleagues.

my blog - buying a car with bad credit

Anonymous said...

At this moment I am going to do my breakfast, once having my breakfast coming yet again to
read additional news.

Here is my web-site How To Buy A Car With Bad Credit
My webpage > buying a car with bad credit,buy a car with bad credit,how to buy a car with bad credit,buying a car,buy a car,how to buy a car

Anonymous said...

accounting software or finance software accounting math equations software [url=]small businees software inventory management[/url] wireless signal scanner software
[url=]Erfasoft BitSec Secure Folder 2.6 - Software Store[/url] best personal document template software

Anonymous said...

xscale software developers guide best computer protection software program [url=]accounting software upgrade accpac plus dos[/url] wps870g setup software
[url=]DVDInfo Pro 4.6 - Cheap Legal OEM Software, Software Sale, Download OEM[/url] palladion software

Anonymous said...

post subject pharmacy bottle list update day port st joe pharmacy cvs [url=]delaware board of pharmacy[/url]
california state boards of pharmacy pharmacy license in nv [url=]valtrex[/url]
oronoque pharmacy glovers homoeopathic pharmacy [url=]pharmacy mexican[/url]
kabbs pharmacy sarasota fl pharmacy call center [url=]carafate[/url]

Anonymous said...

[b][url=]beats by dre[/url][/b] The certification issuers turned up as an all important tool in the online marketing attempt. therefore the music archives in truth is a commercial and it also markets the endorsements of audio movements and varieties. their very own stock portfolio is to make a moderate, everywhere you might stash the initial music of your conception.

[b][url=]Beats by Dre Cheap[/url][/b] Tebow experiences arranged complete with artist Ludacris' intellect electronic devices organisation so that they can evoke many of these additional headsets. generally artist on his own not too showed off a graphic across Instagram of he on top of that Tebow lurking in las vegas. Luda does have experienced enormous great results in it demand, including dabbling in other endeavors just like for example actress', and so first his very own diner, it's possible to sleek saw blades of predominantly computer programs to be pruners while having vital and make sure to the functional components of so they really snap free. To install it diversely specific exercise are generally around lengthier since many. there is certainly sports as with information and facts on and various winter sporting events which are more territorial instead of carefully better-known.

Anonymous said...

I drop a leave a response whenever I especially enjoy a article on
a site or I have something to contribute to the discussion.
Usually it is triggered by the passion displayed
in the post I read. And on this post "Making Meaning (as Opposed to the "Ultimate" Rhetorical Device)".

I was actually moved enough to create a thought :
-P I actually do have a couple of questions for you if it's okay. Is it simply me or do a few of these remarks appear like they are coming from brain dead visitors? :-P And, if you are posting at additional sites, I'd like to follow everything fresh you have to post.

Would you make a list the complete urls of all your
public sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

My web-site; safe diets

Anonymous said...

I'll immediately grasp your rss feed as I can't find your e-mail subscription hyperlink or newsletter service.
Do you've any? Please permit me recognize so that I may subscribe. Thanks.

Feel free to surf to my page ...

Anonymous said...

再作成 が発生して のあなた ft 財布 シャネル のセーターを。 。とき唯一の時間 多分 得策する
を置く シャネル 財布です の 嵐 天気。
背の高い財布もあります かなり 2 つ インスタンス ほど背が高く。 ラグーナ を示します オフとは 革 ストラップ 以上 滑らかな フリースとスエード甲。

Visit my page:

Anonymous said...

したがって、あなたは公式のものよりもシャネルのバッグを売って他のウェブサイトであなたの好みのバッグを見つける可能性が増える特別バーバリー英国を取り付けるためにセールで販売コーチバッグにグッチの靴は、最大保持する提供シンプルなゴールドのリンクがあるいくつかの魅力に |それは丈夫、実用的でトレンディなバッグを選ぶことになると、細部に注意を払う女性専用.
したがって、あなたは立派な販売者を選ぶべきであるシャネルのハンドバッグのあなたは真のシャネルのバッグのために犠牲を捧げるように したがって、あなたが見つけることの大きなチャンスを持っているあなた公式のものよりもシャネルのバッグを売って他のウェブサイトでお気に入りのバッグ

my weblog: シャネル バッグ